In the Bolshoi Ballet's
Swan Lake, the company are dancing well, but Yuri Grigorovich's
concept keeps getting in the way. Grigorovich has recently
revised his 1969 production, dropping the happy ending imposed
by the Soviet regime. Otherwise, this is an early example
of Swan Lake saddled with psychological subtext. The prince
still falls in love with the Swan Queen Odette, only to be
tricked by her wicked double Odile. But Grigorovich is so
busy turning Odette into a figment of the prince's unconscious
that he fudges the ballet.
We're never told that Odette is in the
power of a wicked magician; her fear and pathos are blurred.
The magician is now an Evil Genius who lures the prince to
the lake, leading him on with virtuoso jumps. Far from giving
the prince depth, this turns him into a dull and helpless
puppet. The strenuous new choreography grates against Tchaikovsky's
score.
It's a messy staging. Grigorovich keeps
cutting from palace to lakeside by dropping a gauze curtain
- not just for scene changes, but for any and every dramatic
moment. Simon Virsaladze's designs give us a sludge-brown
palace and a muddy grey lake.
Other principals could cut through all
this. Svetlana Zakharova recently joined the Bolshoi from
the Kirov. The change has done her good: she's dropped her
mannerisms, her overarched backbends, and found a new clarity
of movement. But she remains a chilly technical marvel. Since
leaving the Kirov, she's added a touch of the tragedy queen
to Odette, a little vamping to Odile, but no more. She'll
stop mid-phrase to highlight a pose, but that doesn't give
it dramatic or musical meaning.
She barely notices her prince, but then
Andrei Uvarov is easily overlooked. He has an elegant physique,
a strong jump, clear line and arched feet, but he's a limp
stage presence. For all his strength as a dancer, he lacks
impetus: there's no drive to carry him from one step to the
next.
As the Evil Genius, Dmitri Belogolovtsev
tries to power his way through the role's shortcomings. He
can't give it dramatic shape - it doesn't have one - but he
jumps heroically in the attempt.
The corps of swans have a unified style,
big but soft. Long legs are thrown back, arms upflung. They
hurl themselves into the choreography, but without violence.
The running, flocking swans build up more power than anything
else on stage.
Grigorovich's production robs them of
their other big moment, the national dances, which have been
replaced by pointe shoe numbers. The solo dancing is impressive,
but it's a lost opportunity. This corps pounce on any hint
of folk dance flavour. The Neapolitans have silenced tambourines,
but they beat and shake them with real attack. You can only
guess how powerful this company could be in a real Swan Lake. |